Do Tasers Even Work on Thick Clothing? A Comprehensive Look at Conducted Energy Weapons (CEWs) and Clothing
The effectiveness of a conducted energy weapon (CEW), commonly known as a Taser, when someone is wearing thick clothing is a complex issue with no simple yes or no answer. While Tasers are designed to incapacitate individuals through neuromuscular incapacitation (NMI) by delivering an electrical shock, the presence of thick clothing significantly impacts their effectiveness. This article delves into the science behind CEWs and how different types of clothing affect their performance.
How do Tasers Work?
Tasers work by firing two barbed probes connected to the weapon by thin wires. These probes deliver a high-voltage, low-amperage electrical shock. This shock disrupts the nervous system, causing involuntary muscle contractions and temporary incapacitation. The key here is the need for the probes to make proper contact with the skin to deliver the electrical charge effectively.
What Types of Clothing Impede Taser Effectiveness?
The thickness and material of clothing are crucial factors. Thick, insulating materials are the biggest obstacle. Let's break it down:
-
Thick Coats and Jackets: Heavy winter coats, especially those made from materials like thick wool, down, or synthetic insulation, can significantly reduce or even completely block the electrical current from reaching the skin. The insulation acts as a barrier, preventing the probes from making effective contact.
-
Leather and Denim: While not as insulating as some materials, thick leather and heavy denim can still hinder the electrical conductivity and reduce the effectiveness of the Taser. The probes may struggle to penetrate these materials, or the current might be significantly weakened.
-
Multiple Layers: Wearing multiple layers of clothing, even if each layer is relatively thin, can cumulatively create sufficient insulation to lessen the Taser's impact.
-
Wet Clothing: Ironically, wet clothing can increase conductivity in some cases. While this might seem counterintuitive, the dampness can create a more conductive pathway for the electricity, potentially increasing the chance of effective incapacitation. However, the effectiveness still depends on the type and thickness of the wet clothing.
Do Tasers Always Fail Through Thick Clothing?
No, Tasers don't always fail through thick clothing. The effectiveness depends on several factors, including:
-
Probe Placement: If the probes manage to penetrate the clothing and make good contact with the skin, incapacitation is still possible, even through thicker materials. However, the likelihood of this diminishes with thicker clothing.
-
Voltage and Current: While modern Tasers deliver a high voltage, the amperage remains relatively low. Thick clothing drastically reduces the amount of current reaching the body.
-
Type of Taser: Some Tasers may be more effective than others in penetrating thicker materials due to differences in probe design or power output.
What About "Drive Stun" Mode?
Tasers have a "drive stun" mode, where the weapon itself is pressed against the body. While this bypasses the need for probe penetration, thick clothing still significantly reduces the effectiveness of drive stun, as the insulation prevents sufficient electricity from reaching the body.
What are the Implications for Law Enforcement?
The potential limitations of Tasers when encountering suspects wearing thick clothing are a critical concern for law enforcement. This factor necessitates a reassessment of tactics and an understanding of the reduced effectiveness of CEWs under these circumstances. Other methods of control may be necessary.
Conclusion
In short, the effectiveness of a Taser on someone wearing thick clothing is highly variable and dependent on multiple interacting factors. While not guaranteed to fail completely, the likelihood of successful incapacitation is significantly reduced. This necessitates understanding the limitations of CEWs and adapting tactics accordingly.
